Perception of parasports, part 2

Perception of parasports, part 2

Cate­go­ries galo­re and the quest for fairness

The lar­ge num­ber of cate­go­ries can be descri­bed as a neces­sa­ry evil of parasports. The pur­po­se of the cate­go­ry clas­si­fi­ca­ti­ons is to take into account the dif­fe­rent types and degrees of disa­bi­li­ty and gua­ran­tee a reasonable level of fair­ness and equal oppor­tu­ni­ties. Para­do­xi­cal­ly, all the dif­fe­rent cate­go­ries make parasports a “mas­ter of dif­fe­ren­tia­ti­on and exclu­si­on”. The more cate­go­ries the­re are, the more boun­da­ries are drawn and the more grey are­as crea­ted. This regu­lar­ly leads to dis­con­tent and hea­ted dis­cus­sions – usual­ly about ath­le­tes alle­gedly being assi­gned to the wrong cate­go­ries and a lack of equal oppor­tu­ni­ties. Sin­ce I am in the cate­go­ry with the lowest impair­ment level in my sport, such dis­cus­sions are for­t­u­na­te­ly rare for me.

The many dif­fe­rent cate­go­ries lead to both a frag­men­ta­ti­on of the ath­le­te fields in the indi­vi­du­al cate­go­ries – which are often small alre­a­dy – and to a con­fu­sing situa­ti­on for spec­ta­tors. In my opi­ni­on, a sen­si­ble solu­ti­on for sports with indi­vi­du­al starts has been found in alpi­ne ski­ing. On the basis of a careful­ly cal­cu­la­ted fac­tor, the clock is set to run at dif­fe­rent speeds depen­ding on the athlete’s degree of impair­ment. The ath­le­te who rea­ches the finish line in the “fas­test” time then wins. This method is appli­ed across cate­go­ries and is reason­ab­ly easy for spec­ta­tors to understand.

While some peo­p­le call for more cate­go­ries in order to bet­ter cater to the indi­vi­du­al impairm­ents, others want to see cate­go­ries mer­ged – in favour of lar­ger fields, grea­ter attrac­ti­ve­ness, a reduc­tion in the delu­ge of medals and increased sim­pli­ci­ty. This dis­cus­sion can go so far that one ends up won­de­ring why we don’t sim­ply open up some sports to ever­yo­ne, inclu­ding par­ti­ci­pan­ts wit­hout disa­bi­li­ties? Allow me to ask a pro­vo­ca­ti­ve ques­ti­on: would that not be true inclu­si­on? In some sports, such a solu­ti­on would be almost impos­si­ble to imple­ment – at least not wit­hout put­ting the para-ath­le­tes at a con­sidera­ble dis­ad­van­ta­ge. In my cate­go­ry of wheel­chair ath­le­tics, howe­ver, I could theo­re­ti­cal­ly envi­sa­ge such a sce­na­rio. Com­pe­ti­tors wit­hout disa­bi­li­ties might have an advan­ta­ge thanks to their core strength. Yet at the same time, they could be at a dis­ad­van­ta­ge due to their weight (more mus­cle mass in the legs) and becau­se the sen­sa­ti­on and cir­cu­la­ti­on in their legs might force them to adopt a dif­fe­rent sit­ting posi­ti­on. Of cour­se this remains hypo­the­ti­cal, but it is an ima­gi­na­ti­ve and pro­gres­si­ve idea that is cer­tain­ly wort­hy of con­side­ra­ti­on. The con­ver­se prac­ti­ce of having para-ath­le­tes par­ti­ci­pa­ting in sport­ing com­pe­ti­ti­ons for non-dis­ab­led ath­le­tes is alre­a­dy prac­ti­sed in a small num­ber of cases, albeit sub­ject to cer­tain requi­re­ments and rest­ric­tions. Ger­man long jum­per Mar­kus Rehm has com­pe­ted against ath­le­tes wit­hout pro­sthe­tic lim­bs on a num­ber of occa­si­ons, for example.

For anyo­ne who wants to know more about the com­plex topic of the dif­fe­rent parasports cate­go­ries, I recom­mend the fol­lo­wing blog artic­le by the Swiss Para­ple­gic Group Com­mu­ni­ty.

Not a social event

Just like in non-dis­ab­led sports, an eli­te parasports com­pe­ti­ti­on is defi­ni­te­ly not a social event. The best one wins, peri­od. No one makes any con­ces­si­ons and it is about far more than just taking part. Unfort­u­na­te­ly, many out­si­ders still take a dif­fe­rent view, atta­ching par­ti­cu­lar importance to the social idea in parasports. I’m exag­ge­ra­ting slight­ly, but essen­ti­al­ly they feel that ever­yo­ne should lea­ve the track/pitch/court, etc., a win­ner. My posi­ti­on on this issue is clear: abso­lu­te equa­li­ty and jus­ti­ce do not exist in eli­te sports, only fair­ness. One simp­le reason why the­re can be no equa­li­ty is that our phy­si­cal make-ups natu­ral­ly dif­fer from per­son to per­son. A per­son who is 1.60 met­res (5 foot 3 inches) tall would pro­ba­b­ly think twice befo­re opting for bas­ket­ball as their eli­te sport of choice, and they could hard­ly demand that a sepa­ra­te high-jum­ping cate­go­ry be crea­ted for peo­p­le of their height. Ever­yo­ne must try to achie­ve the best they can with the per­so­nal attri­bu­tes and abili­ties they have, and it is up to them to deci­de whe­ther to enter a com­pe­ti­ti­on or not.

© Gabri­el Mon­net / Swiss Paralympic


Avera­ge age and ambitions

I have noti­ced that in some eli­te-level parasports and cer­tain indi­vi­du­al cate­go­ries, the avera­ge ages are signi­fi­cant­ly hig­her than in their non-dis­ab­led equi­va­lents. Why that is the case is some­thing I can only spe­cu­la­te about. Of cour­se it is legi­ti­ma­te to deci­de for our­sel­ves how long we want to remain acti­ve as eli­te ath­le­tes and we can be glad of every ath­le­te who increa­ses par­ti­ci­pant num­bers. The first time I spo­ke publicly about my thoughts of reti­ring, many well-mea­ning peo­p­le told me that I could defi­ni­te­ly fol­low others’ examp­les and con­ti­nue my care­er as a suc­cessful ath­le­te until at least the age of 60. Alt­hough the fact that peo­p­le didn’t want me to reti­re was flat­te­ring, the­se words of encou­ra­ge­ment also show­ed that parasports still aren’t taken as serious­ly as they should be. I am con­fi­dent, howe­ver, that avera­ge ages will con­ti­nue to fall in parasports and begin to con­ver­ge with tho­se in non-dis­ab­led sports over the next few years, as per­for­mance levels and par­ti­ci­pant num­bers increase. One inte­res­t­ing deve­lo­p­ment has been noti­ceable for some time: whe­re­as in the past, it was pos­si­ble and even com­mon to begin a parasports care­er at an advan­ced age – for ins­tance after an acci­dent at the age of 20 – and go on to reach the top ranks glo­bal­ly, this is prac­ti­cal­ly impos­si­ble in many sports today. Many disci­pli­nes, inclu­ding wheel­chair ath­le­tics, are domi­na­ted by ath­le­tes who have been in wheel­chairs sin­ce child­hood. Logi­cal­ly, the­se ath­le­tes will often have an advan­ta­ge from the out­set. On the one hand, they have been accus­to­med to moving around in a wheel­chair sin­ce their child­hood and have the­r­e­fo­re alre­a­dy deve­lo­ped the requi­red arm and should­er mus­cles, joint strength and motor skills, and on the other, they can start trai­ning and com­pe­ting in their sport much earlier.

Despi­te this, I still see a small num­ber of ath­le­tes of modera­te­ly advan­ced to advan­ced age who have only just star­ted out in parasports and seem to view taking part in the Para­lym­pics and even win­ning a medal as a mat­ter of cour­se. The obs­ta­cles invol­ved and the long, tough path that ath­le­tes have to fol­low to reach this level are often underestimated.

In our socie­ty, we attach gre­at importance to ensu­ring that ever­yo­ne exer­ci­s­es as much as pos­si­ble. This is equal­ly true for peo­p­le with disa­bi­li­ties. A lar­ge popu­la­ti­on of recrea­tio­nal ath­le­tes is fol­lo­wed by a smal­ler group of per­for­mance-ori­en­ted ath­le­tes and an even smal­ler group of eli­te-level athletes.

A pro­mi­sing future

In spi­te of the­se weak­ne­s­ses and the cat­ching-up that a self-cri­ti­cal per­spec­ti­ve shows is nee­ded, the fact is that parasports have evol­ved in a very posi­ti­ve way and will con­ti­nue to do so in the future. Their repu­ta­ti­on and the level of inte­rest they attract have chan­ged and they have beco­me more visi­ble. The­re have also been big advan­ces in terms of inclu­si­on in many are­as. The ath­le­tes and the peo­p­le around them work more pro­fes­sio­nal­ly and meti­cu­lous­ly, and they often recei­ve more sup­port, be it from asso­cia­ti­ons, orga­ni­sa­ti­ons or other part­ners. Fur­ther para­me­ters such as good infra­struc­tu­re (as we have here in Nott­wil) have been put in place and the ath­le­tes are loo­ked after by expert coa­ches. I hope and wish that this will also be pos­si­ble for future generations.

It is encou­ra­ging that achie­ve­ments in cer­tain para-sports are attrac­ting grea­ter rewards in the form of incre­asing pri­ze money. As in my case with mara­thons, in some disci­pli­nes the rewards are even slow­ly con­ver­ging with tho­se of run­ners. This enables more and more pro­fes­sio­nal and semi-pro­fes­sio­nal ath­le­tes to make a living from sport and con­ti­nue to rai­se their level. A lot is hap­pe­ning in a tech­ni­cal sen­se too and renow­ned com­pa­nies are cham­pio­ning new inno­va­tions. Yet the­re is still a gre­at deal of poten­ti­al and much to be done at various levels. Para-sports could be made easier to under­stand and fol­low, for exam­p­le. This can be achie­ved, not least, through more inten­si­ve public rela­ti­ons work in col­la­bo­ra­ti­on with media part­ners and via good com­men­ta­tors at the com­pe­ti­ti­on venues. Parasports are curr­ent­ly going through an exci­ting peri­od of chan­ge and it is essen­ti­al that we stick at it!

Loo­king ahead, I belie­ve that I can see a posi­ti­ve and extre­me­ly exci­ting future for the youn­ger parasports gene­ra­ti­ons. The young ath­le­tes know how to use digi­tal media and take advan­ta­ge of their enorm­ous poten­ti­al. Ever grea­ter audi­en­ces can be rea­ched and strong, rele­vant mes­sa­ges dis­se­mi­na­ted. The dif­fe­rent sports are beco­ming even more pro­fes­sio­nal and attrac­ti­ve and media inte­rest is gro­wing. Young para-ath­le­tes are demons­t­ra­ting a who­le new self-image. They are full of con­fi­dence and know what they are worth – not least thanks to the new atti­tu­de to the inclu­si­on of peo­p­le with disa­bi­li­ties and the pro­gres­si­ve per­cep­ti­on of parasports within society.

Recommend
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIN
Share